🔗 Share this article

Based on newly revealed information from Embark Studios, Arc Raiders appears to utilize generative systems for creating certain voice lines. This news closely resembles the issue that surrounded the studio's earlier release, The Finals.

Title Introduction

Launched on October 30 for Sony's console, PC, and Xbox, Arc Raiders is marketed as a gentler entry point to the loot-and-extract genre. Compared to complex games like Escape from Tarkov, it strives to offer a user-friendly adventure. The title has mostly received positive feedback, currently holding a excellent score on the popular platform based on thousands of gamer feedback.

Development Approach

On the product's platform description, a clear disclosure regarding computer-assisted production draws comparisons: Throughout creation, we might apply procedural and AI-based systems to support content creation. In every instance, the resulting game reflects the artistic expression of our studio staff."

Past Issue

The Finals, a well-received online combat game famous for its responsive controls and demolition-heavy maps, encountered backlash for its implementation of artificial intelligence ahead of its public debut. Throughout its October 2023 open beta, the project's audio lead revealed in a audio program that the studio had employed AI tools for producing vocal tracks. This announcement prompted immediate negative reaction from voice actors and game developers, who stated that computer-created dialogue were of inferior standard compared to human performances and that such methods could replace voice-acting jobs.

Studio Explanation

Reacting to feedback, the company stated that they had hired professional performers to create initial voice lines for The Finals, but expanded these with synthetic voice systems to produce supplementary lines based on those initial performances. The developer's reasoning highlighted the production efficiency gained from this technique.

Present Circumstances

Concerning Arc Raiders, the game's design director commented that the release avoids utilizing AI generation at all," though he avoided specifics on the exact nature of the store notice. He did admit, however, that the identical voice system implemented in The Finals was also incorporated in Arc Raiders.

We employ a mix of live performance content and audio generated via TTS tools in our releases, depending on the situation," commented a company spokesperson. In certain cases, recording real scenes where performers collaborate — allowing performance dynamics and conflict to influence the result — is something that contributes richness to our game worlds that systems cannot duplicate. Other times, particularly if it involves dynamic gameplay announcements, TTS allows us to have customized dialogue where we typically could not for example due to development pace."

Player Reactions

Early feedback to the incorporation of generative tools in Arc Raiders has been relatively mixed, particularly in the early days. Some players have expressed strong opposition.

• Synthetic speech represents a blemish on an generally excellent game," commented one player in a online discussion.
• "I hate that they did it for The Finals and feel regret to hear they employed it once more for this release," commented another.
• The result was instantly apparent in the speech content for one protagonist," observed a third player.

That said, some users have expressed a more tolerant stance.

• It doesn't bother me, they paid voice actors and applied it appropriately," stated one community member.
• "This is as ethical as it currently exists, I'm afraid," concluded another.

The continuing controversy regarding technology adoption in game development appears set to endure as developers juggle development pace with creative quality and responsible practices.